The Great Pizza Debate: Are YOU Team Thin Crust or Deep Dish? (Vagabond Wineguy Weighs In!)

Deep Dish Pizza April 5th

Oh, pizza. Just the word conjures up images of melty mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and that perfect crust. As Vagabond Wineguy, my life revolves around savoring the best flavors the world has to offer, and let me tell you, pizza holds a special place in my heart (and stomach!).

But let’s be real, fellow food lovers. While the love for pizza is practically universal, the style of pizza we adore can spark some seriously passionate debates. Are you the kind of person who folds a thin, crispy New York slice and devours it with gusto? Or do you prefer to grab a fork and knife and dive into the cheesy, saucy depths of a Chicago deep dish?

I’m not going to lie, I appreciate all pizza. Each style offers a unique and delicious experience. But the rivalry? Oh, the rivalry is legendary! It’s the East Coast versus the Midwest, a battle of textures and toppings that has divided friends and families for decades.

The Tale of Two Pizzas: New York vs. Chicago

The most famous pizza showdown boils down to these two iconic styles:

  • New York-Style: Thin, wide slices with a foldable crust, perfect for a quick and satisfying bite. Often topped with simple, classic ingredients.
  • Chicago Deep Dish: A thick, buttery crust forming a deep “dish” filled with layers of cheese, meat, and chunky tomato sauce on top. A true culinary experience requiring utensils and a hearty appetite.

This age-old debate isn’t just anecdotal. In fact, a recent poll showed a near-perfect split:

DO YOU PREFER NEW YORK STYLE (THIN) OR CHICAGO STYLE (DEEP DISH)?

  • New York Style: 49%
  • Chicago Style: 51%

Talk about a close call! It seems the pizza preference pendulum swings almost evenly.

Celebrating the Deep Dish: A Chicago Original

While I appreciate all pizza, let’s give credit where credit is due. The mighty Chicago deep dish has a fascinating history. It was born in the Windy City back in 1943, thanks to the visionary duo of Ike Sewell and Ric Riccardo, who opened the now-famous Uno’s Pizzeria.

Their creation wasn’t just a pizza; it was a culinary statement. The deep, bread-like crust, the generous layers of cheese, and the rich, chunky tomato sauce served on top turned the traditional flatbread into a hearty and unforgettable meal.

The popularity of deep dish exploded, leading to the creation of a national chain and inspiring countless other pizzerias to offer their own take on this iconic style. So, mark your calendars, pizza aficionados, because April 5th is National Deep Dish Pizza Day! It’s the perfect excuse to indulge in this unique and beloved creation.

A Slice of History: The Pizza Timeline

To truly appreciate the journey of pizza, let’s take a quick look at its delicious evolution:

  • 997 A.D.: Pizza’s Forefather: The earliest recorded use of the word “Pizza” appears in a Latin text in Italy. Back then, it referred to simple flatbreads.
  • 18th Century: Pizza Takes ‘Shape’: Originating from the Italian word “pinsere” (to press), modern pizza begins to evolve in Naples, Italy, with the addition of toppings.
  • 19th Century: The Spread of Pizza: Italian immigrants bring their cherished pizza recipes and traditions to the United States, laying the groundwork for its future popularity.
  • 1943: Chicago Deep Dish Pizza: Ike Sewell and Ric Riccardo open “Pizzeria Uno” in Chicago, forever changing the pizza landscape.

Deep Dive into Deep Dish: 5 Interesting Insights

Beyond its deliciousness, deep dish pizza holds some surprising facts:

  1. Fork vs. Fingers: A whopping 20% of Americans believe pizza should be eaten with your hands, not a fork and knife. Deep dish definitely challenges this notion!
  2. Style Doesn’t Matter: A comforting 16% of Americans simply love pizza, regardless of whether it’s thick or thin. Amen to that!
  3. Load It Up!: Another 16% of Americans are all about the toppings. Deep dish provides the perfect vessel for a mountain of delicious ingredients.
  4. Keep It Simple: Conversely, 10% of Americans prefer a basic pizza. Even a simple deep dish with just cheese and sauce can be incredibly satisfying.
  5. The Great Divide: Only 2% of Americans admit to getting into heated debates over New York vs. Chicago style pizza. But we all know that number feels much higher, right? 😉

The Global Pizza Phenomenon: By the Numbers

Pizza’s popularity isn’t just a feeling; it’s backed by some impressive statistics:

  • Worldwide Sales: Over 5 billion pizzas are estimated to be sold globally each year.
  • Global Market Value: The global pizza market represented a staggering $160 billion in sales in 2020, and some projections suggest it could reach over $233 billion by 2023.
  • A Top Contender: Pizza consistently ranks as one of the most popular foods worldwide, with Italian cuisine, its origin, being a global favorite.
  • American Love Affair: Americans consume around 3 billion pizzas annually (some sources even suggest 4 billion including frozen!). That’s approximately 350 slices eaten every second in the U.S.!
  • Weekly Ritual: About 45% of Americans eat pizza at least once a week, and a remarkable 93% indulge at least once a month.
  • US Dominance: The United States accounts for roughly one-third of the entire global pizza consumption.
  • Top Tier: While a definitive global ranking is tricky, pizza consistently appears in the top echelon of the world’s most eaten and beloved foods, alongside other staples like rice dishes, pasta, noodles, and burgers.
  • Convenience King: Pizza is a top 5 most popular room service order and a go-to for delivery, bringing cheesy goodness right to your doorstep.

So, Where Do YOU Stand in the Great Pizza Debate?

As Vagabond Wineguy, I believe in exploring and appreciating all the deliciousness the world has to offer. While I might lean towards a perfectly paired glass of red with a classic New York slice, I can certainly appreciate the comforting indulgence of a Chicago deep dish.

Now it’s your turn! I want to know: Are YOU a New York-style lover or a deep dish devotee? Or are you like the wise 16% who love all pizza equally?

Share your pizza preferences in the comments below! Let’s get this delicious debate going!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Verified by MonsterInsights